Showing posts with label book guilt. Show all posts
Showing posts with label book guilt. Show all posts

Apr 12, 2012

Review: Tessa Masterson Will Go to Prom by Brendan Halpin and Emily Franklin

book cover of Tessa Masterson Will Go to Prom by Brendan Halpin and Emily Franklin  Title: Tessa Masterson Will Go to Prom[Amazon|GoodReads]
  Author: Brendan Halpin [Website|Twitter] and Emily Franklin [Website]
  Standing: Stand alone novel.
  Genre: Young Adult, Contemporary
  Published: March 27th, 2012 by Walker Childrens
  Format: Kindle edition; 257 pages.
  Source: ARC copy from publisher via NetGalley
  Challenge: Completely Contemp Challenge

Lucas and Tessa’s friendship is the stuff of legend in their small Midwestern town. So it’s no surprise when Lucas finally realizes his feelings for Tessa are more than friendship and he asks her to prom. What no one expected, especially Lucas, was for Tessa to come out as a lesbian instead of accepting his heartfelt invitation. Humiliated and confused, Lucas also feels betrayed that his best friend kept such an important secret from him.

What’s worse is Tessa’s decision to wear a tastefully tailored tuxedo to escort her female crush, sparking a firestorm of controversy. Lucas must decide if he should stand on the sidelines or if he should stand by his friend to make sure that Tessa Masterson will go to prom.

Emily Franklin and Brendan Halpin tackle both sides of a ripped-from-the headlines story to show that true friendship will triumph after all.

So…this one’s getting filed under ‘book guilt’ because I honestly had that mental/emotional debate with myself where I wasn’t sure I could be honest about my mediocre feelings for this book.  Why?  Because while I do want to be respected as an honest reviewer, I also don’t want people to get the impression that I harbor views or beliefs that I most adamantly do not.  On the flip side, I can’t pretend to be gung-ho about a book that I didn’t entirely enjoy reading, that wouldn’t be fair to me or that book.  So I just want to say here and now that I am 100% pro gay-rights, and my thoughts on Tessa Masterson Will Go to Prom aren’t some anti-gay statement.  I don’t feel guilty for giving the book a ‘meh’ review, but I do feel guilty that I even considered fudging things to make myself feel better about it.

I have to confess—there are few things I was more ambivalent about as a teen (and still am) than prom.  So maybe that should have been a clue right there that a book starring the word ‘prom’ wouldn’t really be the perfectly fitting glass slipper I’ve been waiting on.  And then when right at the beginning, Luke (one of our two protagonists) asks Tessa (the other) to prom with a grand gesture the whole town can see, I really should have just stopped.  Because I’m that girl.  The one who hates grand gestures and public displays of love of a giant scale.  I hate it when people propose on billboards at sports events, heck, I hate it when people propose in public period.  Something about it just makes me so uncomfortable and awkward.  These were the clues I should have taken and just not read this book, but I didn’t want to let something like the P word intimidate me out of a read, so I powered forward.

Here’s the lowdown.  I’ve determined that I’m not really a fan of the ‘let’s get together and write a book from two characters’ points of view…we can each write a character and go back in forth in first person perspective!’ books.  I read Dash and Lily’s Book of Dares which was also a miss for me, and even though I really liked The Future of Us, I can acknowledge that this is not a style I enjoy.  And then there was the fact that this book had “ABC Family Special” written all over it.  You know, if ABC Family were the type of channel to support “the gay agenda” (I’m assuming they’re not, but I could be wrong.  Modern Family is on ABC).  It was very agenda-driven.  A ‘we have a message!’ type book, that’s so steeped in warm fuzzies and fond sentiments by the end I kind of felt like I was drowning in it.  Sure, it makes you feel good inside to see the things you believe about friendship, love, family, and being who you really are regurgitated so blatantly on a page, but it doesn’t challenge you or make you think.  Tessa Masterson Will Go to Prom is a great book for teens who may need to see a happy ending come out of a ‘gay in small-town middle America’ story, but I don’t think that it’s going to change anyone’s mind in regards to their stance on sexuality.  And that’s okay!  Not every book needs to be the book that challenges the way people think, and sometimes people really need the support and to feel good at the end of the day, but it was all a bit too hug-it-out for me.

The “ripped-from-the-headlines” story that Tessa Masterson Will Go to Prom was based on concerned a Mississippi student, Constance, whose high school prom was cancelled after the school informed her she could not attend prom with a girl, or wearing a tux.  You can read a short ACLU summary here.  Now, admittedly, I don’t know the gritty details of this story, but I had a hard time swallowing a lot of the events in Tessa Masterson Will Go to Prom.  For example, the school does nothing when Tessa’s locker is repeatedly vandalized, to the point that her school work (and presumably) textbooks are destroyed.  In fact, they seem to support the vandalism, and even the custodian will do nothing to help clean the locker indicating that she deserved it.  The school suspends students who openly support Tessa, and indicate that they will attempt to negatively affect students’ acceptance and scholarships into colleges as a result.  I find it pretty tough to believe that professionals in this situation, regardless of personal beliefs, would openly support and participate in this type of bullying of any student for any reason.  I find it particularly hard to believe that not a single adult in this school seems to have stood up for this student.   Tessa Masterson Will Go to Prom was so busy highlighting the negative to make it all that much bigger of a turnaround by the end that they diminished the positive to an unrealistic level.  

My final nitpick is that they used fake brand names close to but not quite the same as the real thing—I hate when books do this.  Can someone explain this to me?  Is this a result of not wanting/having to pay some sort of fee for mentioning Twilight and Good Morning America?  Because honestly?  It just makes the whole book feel like a knock-off brand to me too.  And I don’t care what people try to tell you, knock-offs are pretty much never as good as the name brand.

I will close in saying that there were some great, positive aspects to this book, and I think a lot of readers will love it.  I’d even recommend it if I met the right person for it.  Tessa’s family was wonderful, and my favorite character in the book was Luke’s mom who was downright awesome.  Luke was a bit of a douchenozzle, but as I’ve gone on long enough I suppose I shouldn’t go off on him too, especially since he spends so much time trying to make up for himself.  At any rate, don’t take my review as the end-all-be-all of Tessa Masterson Will Go to Prom.  I’ve included links to some more positive reviews to give you some rounding.

Likelihood that I'll be back for more:  I think I’ve pretty well determined that not only was this book not really my thing, this type of book isn’t really my thing.  To the point that I’ve considered crossing books like Will Grayson, Will Grayson off my list, because I’m pretty sure it just won’t click because of the narrative style.

Recommended for: LGBT teeens, contemporary fans, people who don’t physically cringe or gag over things like grand gestures and prom.

Real life repercussions of reading this book:  I just want to share this response to “I’m Christian, Unless You’re Gay” that came out last week.  I feel like it brought up a lot of the same issues as Tessa Masterson Will Go to Prom, but in a way that made me think and feel more than this book was able to.

Get a second opinion:
Good Books and Good Wine
Imaginary Reads
My Reading Room

Feb 10, 2012

Review: Extremely Loud and Incredibly Close by Jonathan Safran Foer

Book cover of Extremely Loud and Incredibly Close by Johathan Safron Foer
Title: Extremely Loud and Incredibly Close [Amazon|GoodReads]
Author: Jonathan Safron Foer [Website|Facebook]
Standing: Stand alone novel.
Genre: Contemporary
Published: March 7th, 2005 by Houghton Mifflin
Format: Kindle edition; 368 pages.  
Source: Borrowed from my local library.


Sometimes I feel guilty about giving a book a bad rating on GoodReads, and this was one of those times.  I feel guilty because I do not think that this is a bad book whatsoever, and can see why many/most think it is a great book, but it was so glaringly not a good book for me.  I made it only about 60% of the way through, and honestly only got that far because I felt like there was something wrong with me for not appreciating something so many people have fawned over (see also: why I read A Heartbreaking Work of Staggering Genius which I found to be neither heartbreaking nor of staggering genius).  So I want to say up front that while I will discuss why I couldn’t make it through this book, I in no way mean to dissuade others from reading it.


Summary from GoodReads:
Nine-year-old Oskar Schell has embarked on an urgent, secret mission that will take him through the five boroughs of New York. His goal is to find the lock that matches a mysterious key that belonged to his father, who died in the World Trade Center on the morning of September 11. This seemingly impossible task will bring Oskar into contact with survivors of all sorts on an exhilarating, affecting, often hilarious, and ultimately healing journey.

Maybe it makes me a horrible person, but I cannot stand the bulk of books with autistic narrators (I did read and really like The London Eye Mystery, but that is it).  Now, at no point do they come out and say Oskar is autistic, but it’s fairly clear to me that he is on the high functioning end of the spectrum.  This makes the narration very fractured and tangential, forcing the reader to comb for the relevant and important pieces.  I cannot blame this entirely on Oskar, however, because the same must be said of the narration by his grandfather and grandmother, who often share the same stories but remember them very differently.  I do usually like unreliable or mentally fractured narrators, maybe I just couldn’t take having so many of them in one place.  Also, I stylistically get annoyed by run-on paragraphs.  We’re talking paragraphs that go on page, after page, after page, to the point that by the end you have no idea where you were when the paragraph started.

And then there’s the story.  This is entirely a personal issue on my part.  Oskar’s father was killed in 9/11, and he is so angry and depressed that he cannot abide the various coping mechanisms of those around him, in particular his mother.  He is cruel to her, to the point of saying that he wishes she had died instead of his father, and that if she ever loves anyone again he will stop loving her.  Now I know kids get angry and fly off the handle (who of us didn’t yell “I hate you!” to our parents at some point?), but this quite frankly made me dislike Oskar incredibly.  I also can't stand when people use tragedies in their lives to gain access to others, which I feel like Oskar does. Any time he needs to chip away at someone's exterior, he is more than happy to point out that his dad died. Ugh! On top of which, the story is punctuated by pictures that Oskar has taken with his grandfather’s camera, as well as pictures that his grandfather takes himself.  There is one picture that repeats, and that is a picture of a body jumping/falling from the World Trade Center.  This image made my stomach turn each time I saw it, as this footage is permanently stamped on my brain as the most horrible thing I have ever and probably will ever seen in my lifetime.  I couldn’t take it.

Oskar’s family is punctuated by such a deep sadness that it is impossible for the bulk of people to identify.  Oskar has lost his father in 9/11, his grandfather lost the love of his life in the bombing of Dresdan, and down they fall.  All of us experience intense losses in our lives, but even so it is hard to wrap my mind around so many atrocities.  However, I feel like the author tries to counter this by creating an unrealistic New York City.  Almost everyone Oskar encounters (with the exception of the children his age, who are cruel to the ‘weird’ kid) is incredibly patient and kind to such a quirky young man.  That’s great, really, but I don’t think it’s realistic.  Oskar is, by virtue of his being, very inquisitive, and also very knowledgeable about odd topics, and I just don’t see all of these people who meet him for the first time inviting him into their homes and sharing very personal stuff with him.  Some of them, sure, but not as many as do.  Also, his mother just seems like a bad mom.  What mother lets their 10 year old autistic kid wander around NYC on their own on a regular basis?  I’m also not sure that she’s acknowledging, let alone taking steps to assist his special needs.  Yes, she takes him to a therapist, but the kid’s basically self mutilating (yeah, it’s not cutting, but bruising yourself is not far off), and she just wants some kind of wonder fix rather than something that requires her to put more time and attention into their relationship.

Overall, this was just one of those books where I felt like I had no one to root for, and that made it pretty painful for me to read.  The writing really was beautiful, and the story is deeply powerful and probably touching to those who can immerse themselves, but I just couldn’t.  Now excuse me while I go read something with wizards or fairies or some crap like that.

Likelihood that I'll be back for more: I actually checked out both this book and Everything is Illuminated in 2007.  I tried to read the latter, but couldn’t as it was too close to the movie (which was wonderful), and never got around to this one.  Now that I finally have, I can respect him very much as a writer, but acknowledge that he’s probably not for me.  

Recommended for:  This is probably a good book club read, and I’d recommend it to people who enjoy adult contemporaries. Also people who enjoyed Jeremy Fink and the Meaning of Life, as this is kind of the adult flip on that YA novel.

Real life repercussions of reading this book:  Other than experiencing book guilt, I’ve more or less determined I will not be seeing the movie.  Don’t let me stop you though, here’s the trailer:

LinkWithin

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...